MP3 Bitrates compared

A lot of people use some mp3 files right now. I decided to take a look at a spectrum analysis of a sound file at different bitrates. The result is really something, I doesn’t expected..

The original wave file is a radio (FM) recorded… I chose this one, cause this radio have a big noise on the upper part of the spectrum.

Original:

http://jkx.larsen-b.com/photos/blog/spectrum_original.png

b = 128

http://jkx.larsen-b.com/photos/blog/spectrum_128.png

b = 192

http://jkx.larsen-b.com/photos/blog/spectrum_192.png

b = 224

http://jkx.larsen-b.com/photos/blog/spectrum_224.png

Variable bitrate

http://jkx.larsen-b.com/photos/blog/spectrum_variable.png

What we clearly see, it that mp3 encoder (lame here) use a expander, and this is quite a good stuff. I think I should have normalized the input.. but..

After that point, we clearly see it cuts the around 16Khz, I know that my computer system isn’t able to achieve this level, but my stereo system can.

First results show that Ogg give a better results but this is for a future post.

Enjoy sound